Titanium dioxide particles in our diet
Titanium dioxide particles in our diet – effects on the tolerability of titanium implants?
A recent study by the University of Sydney on the effects of titanium dioxide particles (TiO2) in the gut is reiterating the international debate over the use of titanium dioxide in our foods, marked by E171. (1-3)
Titanium dioxide: E171 and Cl77891 – where nanoparticles meet us every day
The whitening agent titanium dioxide has meanwhile become indispensable in our everyday lives. Consumption has increased sharply in the last century, and continues to increase. The additive E171 is found in medicines, plastics, chewing gum, paints, clothing and also in our food, such as mozzarella, instant soups and sweets.
Under the name Cl 77891 the substance is contained in cosmetic products such as toothpaste or as nanoparticles in sun creams. Especially spray applications in which the titanium dioxide enters the lungs, the risk for a carcinogenic effect is highest. For this reason the Federal Institute for Risk Assessment of Germany advised against using sunscreens in spray form as early as 2010. (4)
Official reactions to the use of titanium dioxide
Worldwide, the chemical titan dioxide is produced on a million-ton scale, in Europe alone it is more than 1 million tons per year.
The EU Commission wants to classify titanium dioxide as a hazardous substance with the warning “possibly carcinogenic”, this risk assessment was carried out by the EU chemicals agency ECHA already in 2017 during the inhalation of titanium dioxide.In animal studies, nanoparticles were able to penetrate deep into the lungs and cause chronic inflammation. In rats, lung tumors formed. (5)
The French government has already responded by prohibiting the use of titanium dioxide in food for at least one year from 2020. On January 20, 2017, a French research team published a study by the National Research Institute of Agriculture (INRA), in which rats were given titanium dioxide as drinking water for 100 days. As a result, effects on the immune cells of the Peyer’s plaques, i.e. the place in the intestine, at which immune responses are initiated, were shown by a downregulated expression of T-cells, as well as changes in the intestinal mucosa. In addition, certain inflammatory parameters were increased and a possible tumor-promoting effect was reported. (6)
Three other studies in recent years have shown that intestinal permeability increases with titanium dioxide and proinflammatory cytokine secretion increases. In addition, an effect on human ovaries cannot be excluded, and it has been shown that titanium dioxide has genotoxic potential by promoting the formation of reactive oxygen species. These are a highly reactive compound and can lead to oxidative stress in high concentrations, which is why they have been associated with a variety of diseases such as cancer, diabetes and cardiovascular disease. (7-9)
Nevertheless, the Federal Institute for Risk Assessment does not recognize any reliable scientific arguments that would justify the use of titanium dioxide as a food additive. (10) The results, however, give reason to think about.
Titanium dioxide damages the microbiome of our intestines
In the latest study from the University of Sydney, published on May 14, 2019 in the Frontiers Journal, mice were given drinking water with titania particles for several weeks. Although TiO2 did not affect the composition of the gut microbiota, it did show favoring the activity of the bacteria and the formation of a bacterial biofilm, especially of E. coli and E. faecalis. This bacterial biofilm in the gut is associated with the development of inflammatory bowel disease and colon cancer. (1)
In addition, the length of the intestinal crypts was reduced, the infiltration of CD8 * T cells and macrophages increased and there was a higher expression of inflammatory cytokines. In conclusion, titanium dioxide leads to an increased inflammatory readiness of the intestine.
The University of Zurich, headed by Prof. Gerhard Rogler, is researching the effects of nanoparticles on the intestinal mucosa. Initial results show that especially patients with inflammatory bowel diseases, such as ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease, resulting in a disturbed barrier of the intestinal mucosa due to titanium oxide particles, have markedly increased TiO2 blood levels and a higher risk for an acute inflammation of the gut (11).
It is suspected that diseases such as dementia, asthma, eczema and autism can be triggered by the absorption of titanium dioxide particles.
What effects do titanium implants have on our organism?
The question now is how the increasing oral intake of E171 and increasing environmental exposure affects the ability of our immune system to excite inflammation on titanium oxide particles that are clearly found in the surrounding soft tissue and bone of titanium implants. The passivating protective layer, which spontaneously forms on the titanium surface together with oxygen when exposed to air, ensures corrosion protection. However, it has been shown in numerous studies that this titanium oxide layer can be disturbed and changes under physiological conditions. In animal experiments, titanium loads of parenchymatous organs after hip or dental implants have been shown. The highest accumulation was found in the regional lymph nodes, in the lungs and in the spleen, less in the liver and kidneys. (12)
Overloading, physiological micro-movements of the implant, which leads to continuous shearing of the oxide layer into the tissue (fretting corrosion) or even lowering of the pH in the environment triggered by inflammatory processes, titanium dioxide particles get into the surrounding tissue. The attack of lipopolysaccharides can destroy the oxide film and release suboxides, Ti3 + or TiO +, into the environment. (11)
Also by the negatively charged electrons in the saliva and the positively charged metal ions of the titanium surface upon exposure into the oral cavity, a corrosion process can be initiated by ion exchange. (13) We must assume that titanium implants are not completely biocompatible in the human body and can therefore contribute to the triggering of diseases. This knowledge is not new, as early as 1997, after injection of suspensions of titanium powder, rats developed malignant connective tissue tumors and lymphosarcomas. (13)
Are there allergies to the material titanium?
Allergies to titanium are practically non-existent, which is why a lymphocyte transformation test usually turns out to be negative and conventional medicine therefore rates the material as the material with the best biocompatibility. However, this is a very one-sided approach. Although there is rarely an allergic reaction to a titanium-containing material and then, more typically, to alloying constituents or impurities, such as e.g. Aluminum, nickel or vanadium. Nevertheless, reactions to titanium oxides are very likely, especially under a certain genetic disposition and not allergic, but of inflammatory nature.
A titanium stimulation test can prove the genetic disposition by detecting specific inflammatory messengers. (14). Titanium particles activate tissue macrophages, resulting in an increased release of TNF-alpha and IL-1-ß. TNF-alpha plays a key role in numerous infectious and inflammatory diseases. Osteoclasts are activated and can promote peri-implantitis, a severe bone loss around the implant. (15)
In the surrounding bone, the RANTES / CCL5 values are increased by a factor of 30. The resulting chronic, silent inflammation can contribute to diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis and other systemic-inflammatory diseases. (16)
Titanium oxide particles also significantly slow cell growth and rate of proliferation of gingivofibroblasts and osteoblasts. These mesenchymal cells involved in the synthesis of the connective tissue extracellular matrix showed an inflammatory response to the nanoparticles. (17)
Titanium oxide from the perspective of toxicology
From a toxicological point of view, subtoxic exposure to titanium and its compounds can be medically diagnosed only on the basis of long-term effects. Subtoxic means that a substantial toxic load on the organism is usually well below a toxicologically relevant limit. The organism does not recognize the substance as a toxin because only small doses are supplied, the immune system initiates no defense reaction, which is why the substance can be stored for a long time virtually unhindered until the depot may reach toxic relevant doses.
The mechanism of action of titanium oxide is probably similar to that of other metals. These include the inhibition of enzyme activity and thus of the metabolism, increased formation of free radicals, opening of the blood-brain barrier and corresponding psycho-neuro-immunological effects. (18) From the toxicology it is known that titanium dioxide leads to inflammatory and fibrotic changes from an individually different, critical dose and that metal ions (nickel, titanium, cadmium and probably also mercury) have a carcinogenic activity. (13)
Inflammatory mediators can be laboratory-verified, chronic-toxicological reactions, however, often only with hindsight on the basis of the disease, such as in the autoimmune diseases rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis or Parkinson’s disease.
All of these findings show that not only should we look more closely at purchasing food and focus on natural and organic food, but that we should also use biologically compatible materials in dentistry, such as zirconium dioxide, that do not burden the health of our patients additionally.
The question remains open as to how the increasing consumption of TiO2, which we can hardly avoid nowadays, affects the tolerability of titanium implants. That can only be demonstrated by scientifically based long-term studies and the consistent critical consideration of the use of metallic materials in dentistry, especially in chronically and severely ill patients. The safest way here is the consistent renouncement of these materials with simultaneous immunological and biological stabilization of our patients as done in the SWISS BIOHEALTH CLINIC in Kreuzlingen with over 35 years of experience in biological medicine and in the field of ceramic implants.
Dr. Rebekka Hueber
SWISS BIOHEALTH ACADEMY MEMBER
1. Impact of the Food Additive Titanium Dioxide (E171) on Gut Microbiota-Host Interaction. Gabriela Pinget, Jian Tan et al. Stan. University of Sydney : s.n., May 14, 2019, Front. Nutr.
2. Focus online. [Online] https://www.focus.de/gesundheit/news/zusatzstoff-titandioxid-e171-zerstoert-darmflora-und-kann-darmkrebs-beguenstigen-farbstoff-auch-in-mozzarella-enthalten_id_10750495.html.
3. Nau media AG. [Online] https://www.nau.ch/news/ausland/darmflora-nimmt-schaden-durch-den-lebensmittelzusatzstoff-e171-65525681.
4. Risikobewertung, Bundesinstitut für. Sonnenschutzmittel: Zinkoxid als UV-Filter ist nach derzeitigem Kenntnisstand gesundheitlich unbedenklich. Stellungnahme Nr. 037/2010. [Online] Juni 18, 2010.
5. Summary of Classification and Labelling of Titanium dioxide. https://echa.europa.eu/de/information-on-chemicals/cl-inventory-database/-/discli/details/100661. [Online]
6. Foodgrade TiO2 impairs intestinal and systemic immune homeostasis, initiates preneoplastic lesions and promotes aberrant crypt development in the rat colon. Bettini S, Boutet-Robinet E, Cartier C, Coméra C, Gaultier E, Dupuy J, et al. s.l. : Scientific Reports.
7. Titanium dioxide nanoparticle ingestion alters nutrient absorption in an in vitro model of the small intestine. Guo Z, Martucci N, Moreno-Olivas F, Tako E and Mahler G (2017):. 5, s.l. : NanoImpact, 2017, pp. 70-82.
8. Risk assessment of titanium dioxide nanoparticles via oral exposure, including toxicokinetic considerations. Heringa MB, Geraets L, van Eijkeren JCH, Vandebriel RJ, deJong W and Oomen AG. 10, s.l. : Nanotoxicology, 2016.
9. Titanium dioxide food additive (E 171) induces ROS formation and genotoxicity: contribution of micro and nano-sized fractions. Proquin H, Rodriguez-Ibarra C, Moonen CG, Urrutia-Ortega IM, Briede JJ, de Kok TM, van Loveren H and Chirino Y. 32, s.l. : Mutagenesis, 2017, pp. 139-149.
10. Risikobewertung, Bundesinstitut für. Titandioxid – es besteht noch Forschungsbedarf. [Online] Mai 22, 2019. https://mobil.bfr.bund.de/cm/343/titandioxid-es-besteht-noch-forschungsbedarf.pdf.
11. Titanium dioxide nanoparticles exacerbate DSS-induced colitis: role of the NLRP3 inflammasome. Ruiz PA, Morón B, et al. Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland : s.n., Juli 2017, Gut.
12. Ysuharu Nakashima, M.D.†, Doo-Hoon Sun, M.D.†, et al. Signaling Pathways for Tumor Necrosis Factor-α and Interleukin-6 Expression in Human Macrophages Exposed to Titanium-Alloy Particulate Debris in Vitro. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999, Vol. 81, 5, pp. 603-15.
13. Marquardt H, Schäfer S. Lehrbuch der Toxikologie. Heidelberg/Berlin : Spektrum Akademischer Verlag, 1997.
14. Berlin, IMD Labor. Titan-Unverträglichkeitstest. [Online] https://www.imd-berlin.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Diag_Info/210_Titanunvertraeglichkeit.pdf.
15. Safioti LM, Kotsakis GA, Pozhitkov AE, Chung WO, Daubert DM1. Increased Levels of Dissolved Titanium Are Associated With Peri-Implantitis – A Cross-Sectional Study. J Periodontol. 2017, 88.
16. Lechner J, Noumbissi S, von Baehr V. Titanium implants and silent inflammation in jawbone-a critical interplay of dissolved titanium particles and cytokines TNF-α and RANTES/CCL5 on overall health? EPMA. Juni 08, 2018, 9(3).
17. Sonja Sielker, Arndt Happe, Susanne Jung, Johannes Kleinheinz. Zytotoxischer Einfluss von Titanpartikel im μm-Be- reich auf humane Osteoblasten und Gingivafibroblas- ten in vitro.
18. Graf, Karlheinz. Störfeld Zahn. München : Elsevier Verlag, 2010.
19. Bacterial biofilms in colorectal cancer initiation and progression. Li S, Konstantinov SR, Smits R, Peppelenbosch MP. 2017, Trends Mol Med., pp. 23:18-30.
Cover photo (c) Svariophoto – stock.adobe.com